Press and Information Division
PRESS RELEASE No 83/03
2 October 2003
Judgment of the Court of Justice in Case-C-232/01
Criminal proceedings against Hans Van Lent
BELGIAN RULES THAT REQUIRE RESIDENTS' MOTOR VEHICLES TO BE REGISTERED IN BELGIUM ARE
CONTRARY TO THE PRINCIPLE OF FREEDOM OF MOVEMENT FOR WORKERS
The Court holds that such a measure cannot be justified on grounds of
road safety or of combating erosion of the tax base
He works in Luxembourg during the week and his employer has provided him
with a vehicle leased from a company established in Luxembourg. Mr Van Lent
also used the vehicle for private purposes to go home and at the
weekend.
Belgian rules require residents' vehicles to be registered in Belgium in the name
of their owner.
Following a traffic check in Belgium in 1999, the Belgian authorities commenced criminal
proceedings against Mr Van Lent for infringing the Belgian rules. However, Mr Van Lent
could not register the vehicle in Belgium because the owner was the leasing
company. The Belgian court referred a question to the Court of Justice of
the European Communities on the compatibility of the Belgian rules with the principle
of freedom of movement for workers under the EC Treaty.
The Court states that, in the absence of harmonisation in the field, Member
States may prescribe the conditions for registration of vehicles in their territory. They
must, however, comply with the provisions of the EC Treaty on freedom of
movement for workers. Those provisions are intended to facilitate the pursuit by Community
nationals of occupational activities in the territory of the Community and preclude measures
which might undermine that objective.
The difficulties created by the Belgian rules may discourage an employer in another
Member State from engaging a Belgian worker. They may also deter Belgian workers
from exercising their right to freedom of movement.
Ensuring road safety and combating erosion of the tax base, the objectives underlying
the obligation to register vehicles, cannot be achieved by the Belgian legislation since
the vehicle cannot be registered in that country. The Court therefore believes that
the Belgian rules are not justified.
Since August 2001, the new Belgian rules authorise the user of a vehicle
resident in Belgium, to register it there when the owner is unable to
do so because he is established outside Belgian territory. The Court states, however,
that even that possibility of registering the vehicle introduced by the new Belgian
rules cannot justify the obstacles which remain in respect of freedom of movement
for workers.
Unofficial document, for media use only, which does not bind the Court of Justice. Available languages: DA, DE, EN, FR, NL. The full text of the judgment can be found on the internet (www.curia.eu.int ). In principle it will be available from midday CET on the day of delivery. For additional information please contact Christopher Fretwell. Tel: (00352) 4303 3355 Fax: (00352) 4303 2731 |